All Flavors

Explore Our Handcrafted Popcorn Flavors

At Shipshewana Popcorn Company, every kernel tells a story—of small-town charm, handcrafted quality, and bold, unforgettable flavor. We make all of our popcorn in small batches, right here in Shipshewana, Indiana, using non-GMO kernels and time-tested recipes. Whether you’re craving something sweet, savory, or a little of both, there’s a Shipshewana flavor to match every mood and occasion.

Sweet Flavors

Our sweet varieties are made with indulgent glazes and creative flavor combinations that take classic popcorn to the next level. Enjoy our rich, buttery Caramel Popcorn—an all-time favorite that’s crisp, golden, and melt-in-your-mouth good. For those who love a hint of spice with their sweets, Sweet Heat offers a surprising kick of cayenne balanced perfectly with caramel. And for chocolate lovers, Dark Chocolate Cashew delivers a decadent mix of sweet and nutty in every bite.

Savory Favorites

If savory is more your style, we’ve got you covered. White Cheddar is a creamy, cheesy classic that’s both bold and addicting. Prefer something with a little more punch? Pepper Pop turns up the heat with a five-pepper blend that includes jalapeño, habanero, cayenne, serrano, and poblano—a fiery favorite for the brave snackers out there.

The Best of Both Worlds

Can’t decide between salty and sweet? Our Sampler Platter is the perfect solution. It includes a mix of our bestselling sweet and savory flavors, so you can enjoy a little bit of everything or share with friends and family.

Made Fresh, Always

What makes our popcorn different? Every batch is made by hand in our local facility with attention to detail and commitment to freshness. Many of our flavors are gluten-free, and we’re always developing new seasonal favorites to keep things exciting.

Come discover your next favorite flavor—and taste the Shipshewana difference in every bite.